H.Kishie Singh is based in Chandigarh and has been a motoring correspondent for newspapers like The Statesman, New Delhi and The Tribune.His column ‘Good Motoring’, for The Tribune ran for over 27 years. He has been also been the contributing editor for magazines like Car & Bike, Auto Motor & Sport and Auto India. His latest book Good Motoring was published recently and has co-authored a book with The Dalai Lama, Ruskin Bond, Khuswant Singh and others, called The Whispering Deodars.


Saturday 19 December 2020

THE COVID SEATING PLAN


It is really quite remarkable that a pandemic can dictate how you sit in your car.

So fat it was simple. Maa and Paa in the front two seats children, friends or relatives in the back seat. No more! The do-gaj doori has changed all that.

With two people in car, Paa is in the driver’s seat, he sits on the front right. tMaa must sit in the rear left seat. That is as far away as possible. Do-gaj doori.

The idea being that the air exhaled by one person should not be inhaled by the other person. It is recommended that even husband and wife must wear masks.

Now to the next set of instructions. Which window should be open?

In the summer month, with AC on, all windows are rolled up. All four windows rolled up is not recommended. But who is going to drive around in the summer without the AC? So there is no control over who is inhaling and who is exhaling! Which is why curfew was imposed. Stay at home and be safe!

Ideally it would be safest to drive with all four windows open. This will never happen, we want luxury and not safety!

So the worst case is, all four windows closed, a bad combination. The AC is on, the air is being re-circulated. This becomes the highest risk configuration.

These findings were done by two Indian Professors in the USA. Verghese Mathai at the University of Massachusetes and Asimanshu Das of Brown University, USA.

They examined the air flow inside a Toyota Prius moving at 50 mph (80 kmph) with various configuration of windows open and closed.

The common sense move by the average person would be to open the window next to him/her. This option, to open and to closed windows, was not the best configuration the Professors said. So much for common sense!

For two persons in the car, if two windows are to be open, they should be the windows on the opposite side.

The driver should have the front left window open. The passenger in the rear left, should have the rear right window open.

The highest ‘At risk’ person, it turns out, is the driver! This is because that in a moving car air enters the car from the rear window and exit from the front window.

If the windows, all four of them are open, creates two independent air flows on the right and left side of the car interior. In this case very few germs are transmitted between passengers sitting front right and rear left.

Again, this will never happen. It is simply not practical to drive a car, even in the city at a slow speed with all four windows rolled down.

Next option according to the Professors. Three open windows are better than two open windows. That make sense.

But which three windows should be open.

Says Professor Verghese Mathai, ‘ not that once we have two or more windows open the concentration of air bone particles does not build up as much as there is good cross ventilation and dilution of air’.

Three open windows are better than two. Yes we agreed to that. But choosing which window to close makes all the difference! In such a case it would be best if the non-infected person is closest to the closed window.

Who is the affected person? This calls for a covid test.

Or you can through this whole idea out the window! It want make a difference which window!

Stay safe stay at home.